Monday, September 28th, 2009

In a debate on the issue of selling organs, are you for or against?

LONDON: At least a dozen Britons have offered to sell their kidneys for 25,000 pounds or more each to beat credit crunch and pay off their debts, a media report said today.

Their advertisements offering kidney have appeared on the internet and five of them corresponded with undercover journalists, who posed as friends and relatives of sick patients to negotiate sales, The Sunday Times claimed.

One person willing to sell a kidney is a 26-year-old mental health nurse who said he wanted the money to pay debts after his business collapsed. Another, a 43-year-old taxi driver from Lancashire, sought to raise the cash to pay off some of his mortgage and buy a new kitchen.

Meanwhile, a leading doctor said the phenomenon highlighted the need for a public debate on the issue of selling organs.

Professor Peter Friend, a former president of the British Transplant Society, said, "The West has outlawed it for all sorts of good reasons, but the result is it goes underground. It is really important to have a debate."

About 7,000 people in the UK are waiting for kidney transplants and 300 died last year while on the waiting list.

Offering to sell an organ in England, Wales and Northern Ireland is an offence under the Human Tissue Act even if the seller is planning to travel to another country for the transplant operation.

If it saved a life I would, but I would only do it for free.

My sister-in-law has had 2 kidney transplants, the first failed, and the second was donated by her sister. She now lives a dialysis free life.

9 Responses to “In a debate on the issue of selling organs, are you for or against?”

Captain Bonanza Says:

Its A Win Win Scenario For Everyone Invloved
I See No Problem With It
References :

~~Birdy~~ Says:

It could lead to problems but it is their body so they should be able to sell their own parts if they want to.

25,000 pounds would not be nearly enough for me. You can’t afford dialysis with that.
References :

Tigerlily phooey Says:

I wouldn’t buy one as I know I’ll get one for free.However,if I had only months to live and I had the cash I might consider buying it,its not as if its being ripped out of a poor Indian person and sold for peanuts.
References :

Frantastical Says:

Whilst it’s illegal, against.
If it were legal then it’d perhaps mean there are
more kidneys as donors would increase due to cash rewards buy would that mean donors who gave without cash reward would decrease? Therefore those without money would struggle to get one.
References :

Bear Says:

Their body,theirs to sell their own organs.
References :

M Says:

I’d rather die than buy a kidney. I really couldn’t live the rest of my life having done that.

yes, I’ll accept kidney failure, and the fact it’s illegal for a very good reason.
References :

NutstersChick Says:

Against.
Trading of body-parts ( blood, tissue, organs ) is contrary to Gods law of ethics.
Sharing of DNA is a sin in his eyes & who am I to challenge God?
References :

legs Says:

I do not agree with selling organs but it would help with reducing the amount of patients waiting for organs. If it was to become legal in the UK then it would have to be tightly regulated with health checks on the donor before organs could be harvested. This needs open debate as I can see the benefits but would hope for very tight regulation on who can donate - question of being paid is unethical - we don’t get paid for blood donations so why should we get paid for organ donation?
References :

regardless Says:

If it saved a life I would, but I would only do it for free.

My sister-in-law has had 2 kidney transplants, the first failed, and the second was donated by her sister. She now lives a dialysis free life.
References :

Leave a Reply